When Darkness Fell: Jennifer Cave Podcast
Podcast Episodes Shop the Brewery

When Darkness Fell: Jennifer Cave

In Episode 373

Jennifer Cave and Colton Pitonyak had their addiction to drugs in common, but they were otherwise two very different people. Jennifer was known as a caring person who tried to help everyone she met.  Pitonyak was a drug dealer with a growing propensity for violence.

In August of 2005, when Jennifer didn’t show up for her new job working for a law firm in Austin, Texas, her employer called Jennifer’s mother Sharon back in Corpus Christi.  Concerned, Sharon called several of Jennifer’s friends.  She even called Pitonyak, who lied to her and claimed he had not seen Jennifer.  The next day, Sharon and her fiancé, Jim, drove to Austin to look for Jennifer.  The crime scene they found in Pitonyak’s apartment was shockingly gruesome.

Join us at the quiet end for When Darkness Fell. Colton Pitonyak was a former rich kid who was used to getting everything he wanted.  Jennifer considered herself his friend, but he wanted more from her.  He took Jennifer out for dinner to celebrate her new job on August 16th, but something very dark occurred back at his place.  There has never been a clear motive for what happened to Jennifer that night, but it soon became clear to investigators that Pitonyak had had a co-conspirator after the fact.  Once arrested, Pitonyak and his accomplice turned on each other, further deepening the mystery of motive and blame.

Send us a note

Shop Merch

Subscribe for bonus and ad-free shows!

Record a voicemail for an upcoming show

Become a member of our True Crime Brewery Fan Discussion Group

    Jennifer Cave, Colton Pitonyak, Laura Hall 

Apr 19 2021
True Crime
  • Podcast Archive

  • Episode Supported By

    This episode has been monetized by our friends at Spreaker!


    Leave a Reply

    Subscribe Now

    Join Team Tiegrabber and subscribe to our premium podcasts

    You get access to our members-only True Crime Brewery Premium episodes and other members-only true crime content.

    In appreciation, Jill will send you a thank you gift of your choice.

    Pick from a True Crime Brewery beer snifter, a True Crime Brewery credit-card sized bottle opener, or a set of coasters!

    True Crime Newsletter

    Enjoying True Crime Brewery?

    Then you’ll want to receive our quarterly true crime podcast newsletter.

    The True Crime Brewery newsletter is just the thing to feed your true crime addiction. Packed with case updates, true crime show and book reviews, listener-contributed articles, craft beer news, meet up plans and contest announcements

    Get the latest from Tiegrabber Podcasts


    You can listen to the True Crime Brewery podcast here on the site or on the podcast app of your choice