What She Wanted: The Plot to Kill Jay Orbin Podcast
Podcast Episodes Shop the Brewery

What She Wanted: The Plot to Kill Jay Orbin

In Episode 439

Jay Orbin lived to be exactly forty-five years old.  He was murdered on September 8, 2004, which was his forty-fifth birthday.  It was just over a month later when his decomposing torso was found in a Rubbermaid container in the Phoenix desert.

Everyone would agree that Jay had been kind and hard-working.  He was a self-made man and a loving father.  Unfortunately, he was married to a conniving and cold-hearted woman who would stop at nothing to get what she wanted. Jay met his future wife, Marjorie, while she was working at a Phoenix strip club.  She was just Jay’s type– a beautiful, blonde, big-breasted, exotic dancer.  Soon he was calling her “the love of his life.”

Join us at the quiet end for What She Wanted: The Plot to Kill Jay Orbin. Jay and Marjorie married and eventually had a child together.  But Marjorie wasn’t cut out for long-term monogamy.  She had multiple extramarital affairs while married to Jay and she soon wanted him out of her way.  But leaving him was not an acceptable solution for Marjorie, who wanted to keep all of Jay’s money for herself.  So, she decided that murder was the only solution.

Support the show for ad-free and bonus episodes and more!

Record a voicemail for a future show

Contact Us

Shop TCB Merch

Join our True Crime Brewery Fan Discussion Group

Read “Dancing with Death”


“Dancing with Death” by Shanna Hogan

Diary of a Showgirl, 48 Hours, November 13, 2010

Inmate Profile with Arizona Department of Corrections, Retrieved February 25, 2022

State v. Orbin, Court of Appeals State of Arizona Division One, November 3, 2011


Jay & Noah Orbin



Mar 07 2022
True Crime
  • Podcast Archive

  • Episode Supported By

    This episode has been monetized by our friends at Spreaker!


    Leave a Reply


    • This is the first time I’ve listened to a behind the scenes breakdown like this. It’s very interesting to understand how the defense evolved. I was specifically impressed with the assessment of the slippers. Thank-you for providing such unique and informative back stories!
      Carla Stone

    Subscribe Now

    Join Team Tiegrabber and subscribe to our premium podcasts

    You get access to our members-only True Crime Brewery Premium episodes and other members-only true crime content.

    In appreciation, Jill will send you a thank you gift of your choice.

    Pick from a True Crime Brewery beer snifter, a True Crime Brewery credit-card sized bottle opener, or a set of coasters!

    True Crime Newsletter

    Enjoying True Crime Brewery?

    Then you’ll want to receive our quarterly true crime podcast newsletter.

    The True Crime Brewery newsletter is just the thing to feed your true crime addiction. Packed with case updates, true crime show and book reviews, listener-contributed articles, craft beer news, meet up plans and contest announcements

    Get the latest from Tiegrabber Podcasts


    You can listen to the True Crime Brewery podcast here on the site or on the podcast app of your choice