On this episode of True Crime Brewery, we turn our attention to a case that shook a quiet community and left a trail of questions in its wake. In 2015, three people vanished without explanation, sparking concern, confusion, and a growing sense that something sinister had occurred. As investigators found clues and began piecing together the timeline, attention shifted toward someone who seemed unlikely to be at the center of this crime—Kit Martin, a neighbor, a commercial pilot, and a former military officer whose past stood in stark contrast to the accusations that would follow.

As we step through the details in this case, we will explore how a series of disappearances turned into a complex investigation uncovering hidden tensions, troubling relationships, and a web of secrets.

Join us for The House on Old Mill Road. Today we examine the evidence, the contradictions, and the events that brought this case into the spotlight—raising difficult questions about trust, reputation, and what people are truly capable of behind closed doors.

Sources

Christian Richard Martin v. Commonwealth of Kentucky, Appeal, Supreme Court of Kentucky, 10/26/2023.

I Will Ruin You by Emilio Corsetti III

KY v. Christian Martin: Pilot Triple Murder Trial, Court TV Archives, Retrieved 6/14/2026.

The Evil That Watches, Dateline, 9/24/2021.